** Multiple Choice and True or False Test **

Gorean Magistrate: A Test of Knowledge

---

1. What is the fundamental purpose of law in Gorean society? a) To maintain order. b) To protect citizens. c) To preserve the honor of the city and its people. d) All of the above.

• Correct Answer: d) All of the above. The law in Gorean society is used to maintain order, protect citizens, and preserve the honor of the city and its people.

2. With whom does the burden of proof for a conviction lie? a) The accuser. b) The Advocate. c) The defendant. d) The Magistrate.

• Correct Answer: a) The accuser. The accuser must present evidence to convince the Magistrate of the defendant's guilt.

3. What is the ultimate source of law in a Gorean city? a) The Law of the Home Stone. b) The will of the Ubar. c) The traditions of the Scribe Caste. d) All of the above.

• Correct Answer: d) All of the above. The Home Stone represents civic identity, the Ubar's will can be law, and the Scribe Caste's traditions inform legal practice.

4. True or False: The primary duty of a Magistrate is to interpret and apply the law.

• Correct Answer: True. This is the Magistrate's fundamental role as a judge.

5. How would you handle a dispute between a Builder and a Scribe? a) Apply the Law of the Builder Caste. b) Apply the Law of the Scribe Caste. c) Applying the Law of the Home Stone. d) All of the above.

• Correct Answer: c) Applying the Law of the Home Stone. The Law of the Home Stone is the highest law in a Gorean city and applies to all castes.

6. True or False: A Magistrate can create a new law.

• Correct Answer: False. Only the Ubar or High Council has the authority to create new laws.

7. What is the most severe punishment a Magistrate can impose? a) Impalement. b) Outlawry. c) Flogging. d) Slavery.

• Correct Answer: b) Outlawry. Outlawry is a severe punishment that removes a person's legal standing and protection.

8. True or False: A "trial by combat" is a legal function and is overseen by a Magistrate.

• Correct Answer: False. Trial by combat is a warrior's rite, but a Magistrate can be asked to oversee a duel.

9. What is the difference between a legal edict and a judgment? a) An edict is a new law issued by the Magistrate. b) An edict is issued by the Warrior Caste. c) A judgment is a new law issued by the Magistrate. d) A judgment is a Magistrate's ruling in a specific case.

• Correct Answer: d) A judgment is a Magistrate's ruling in a specific case. A legal edict is a new law, while a judgment is the Magistrate's decision in a specific case.

10. What happens if a summoned person fails to appear in court? a) The case is ignored. b) They will not be found guilty. c) They can be declared an outlaw, depending on the original crime's severity. d) A new date and time will be scheduled.

• Correct Answer: c) They can be declared an outlaw, depending on the original crime's severity. Failing to appear before the law is a serious offense in Gorean society.

11. What is the relationship between a Magistrate and the city's High Council? a) The High Council is the city's governing body. b) A Magistrate is subject to its authority. c) May be called upon to advise on legal matters. d) All of the above.

• Correct Answer: d) All of the above. The High Council is the city's governing body, and a Magistrate is subject to its authority and may be called upon to advise on legal matters.

12. A foreign dignitary is accused of a crime within your city's walls. How would you handle the situation? a) They should be released and escorted out of our city. b) They should be jailed and the other city contacted. c) They should be put on trial. d) All of the above.

• Correct Answer: a) They should be released and escorted out of our city. A foreign dignitary has diplomatic immunity and should not be punished in your city.

13. What is the importance of a public trial? a) Entertainment. b) To ensure transparency and accountability. c) To allow the populace to laugh. d) Something to do on the weekend.

• Correct Answer: b) To ensure transparency and accountability. A public trial is held to ensure that the law is upheld and that the people can see that justice is done.

14. Who is responsible for enforcing a Magistrate's judgment? a) The legal clerk. b) The Warriors. c) The banker. d) The prosecutor.

• Correct Answer: b) The Warriors. The Warriors are the city's enforcers, and they execute the Magistrate's judgments.

15. True or False: A Scribe accused of falsifying a record is subject to a fine and demotion as a legal consequence.

• Correct Answer: False. The legal consequence for a Scribe accused of falsifying a record is a punishment determined by the Magistrate.

16. True or False: A Head of Caste has legal authority over their own caste members, which is still subject to the Law of the Home Stone and the Ubar.

• Correct Answer: True. A Head of Caste's authority is limited by the Law of the Home Stone and the Ubar.

17. What would a Magistrate do to ensure that the populace understands the law? a) Post legal decrees in the courtroom. b) Personally announce verdicts in the city square. c) Participate in public teaching circles and forums. d) Rely on citizens to learn the laws themselves.

• Correct Answer: c) Participate in public teaching circles and forums. This is a proactive way to educate the populace and ensure understanding.

18. True or False: A Magistrate cannot reduce a sentence.

• Correct Answer: False. A Magistrate may have a number of sentencing options that may lead to reducing the time or severity of a sentence.

19. A warrior is accused of a crime. How is the case handled? a) A public trial is held. b) A warrior would be tried by his peers and a Magistrate. c) A trial is held in the Magistrate's office. d) Any of the above.

• Correct Answer: b) A warrior would be tried by his peers and a Magistrate. A warrior is tried by his peers and a Magistrate to ensure that the Warrior Code is upheld.

20. True or False: A free woman accused of insulting a High Caste member can be fined or publicly humiliated for disrespecting a member of a high caste, as this would be seen as a crime against social order.

• Correct Answer: True. Disrespecting a High Caste member can be seen as a crime against social order.

Growing list of questions ....

Questions for a Magistrate:

1. The Gorean Magistrate is primarily responsible for:  A. Maintaining the city's calendar and astronomical records.  B. Adjudicating legal disputes and pronouncing judgments.  C. Presenting a legal case on behalf of a client.  D. Negotiating trade treaties with other cities. 

B. 

2. A Gorean Advocate's primary duty is to:  A. Provide legal representation and counsel to a client.  B.  Enforce the will of the Ubar through martial law.  C. Oversee te city's finances and tax collection.  D. Create and maintain the city's architectural plans.  

A.  

3. True or False: A Magistrate's duty is to a specific cllient, while an Advocate's duty is to the city's law.

False. 

4. Which of these is a duty of an Advocate?  A. Advising a client on the best legal strategy.  B.  Ruling on the admissibility of evidence.  C. Maintaining order and decorum in the courtroom.  D. Pronouncing a verdict of guilt or innocence.

 A.

5.  Which of these is a duty of a Magistrate?  A. Conducting interviews with potential witnesses for a client.  B. Interpreting city laws and caste codes to resolve a dispute.  C. Negotiating a prisoner's ransom with a foreign city.  D. Presenting a summary of a case to a jury,

B.

6. Who is responsible for ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to be heard in a trial?  A. The guardsman present in the courtroom.  B. The Advocate of the accused.  C. The accuser or plaintiff.  D. The Magistrate presiding ove the case.

D.

7. Which of the following is the primary task for an Advocate in a criminal trial?  A. Determining if a defendant has a prior criminal record.  B. Consulting with the High Council on the verdict.  C. Approving a search of the defendant'd property.  D. Calling witnesses to support a client's defense. 

D.

8. True or False: A Magistrate must remain silent during a trial and not ask any questiins of the witnesses.

False

9. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt?  A. The Magistrate presiding over her case.  B. The Ubar of the city by decree,  C. An Advocate representing her creditors.  D.   The Warrior who captured her.

A.

10.  When a Magistrate is cinducting a trail, their primary goal is to:   A. Prove the guilt of the accused.  B. Listen to the plaintiff and support their claims.  C. Find a creative punishment for the accused.  D. Ensure that the law is applied fairly and proceedings are orderly.

D.

11. A key difference in demeanor between a Magistrate and an Advocate in a trial is:  A. The Advocate is dressed in blue, while the Magistrate wears scarlet.  B. The Magistrate must remain impartial, while the Advocate's arguments are partisan.  C. The Advocate must remain silent, while the Magistrate does all the talking.  D, The Magistrate must be respectful to all, while the Advocate can be rude to opponents.  

B.

12.  Who is responsible for raising objections during a trial to ensure evidrne is legally sound?  A. The Magistrate.  B. The scribe taking notes.  C. The Litigator for the city.  D.  The defendant.

C.

13.  Who has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court?  A. An Advocate.  B. A civilian who id a witness.  C. A Magistrate,  D.  A warrior.  

C.

14. A Magistrate's office is primarily used for: A. Training new warriors in combat,  B. Managing a citizen's private business.  C. Overseeing the maintenance of city roads.  D. Conducting trials and administrative work.  

D.

15.  Which of these legal concepts is more relevant to an Advocate's duties?  A. Negotiation.  B. Juriddiction.  C. Precendent.  D. Sentencing,  

A.

16.  Who holds the authority to refer a case to a specific caste's leaders for judgment?  A. A commin citizen who is a witness.  B. A Magistrate.  C. An Advocate, if their client is from that caste. D. The Head of the Warrior Caste.  

B. 

17.  A Magistrate's judgement is less effective if:  A. The Advocate is more skilled in rhetoric. B. The case is not properly documented by a scribe.  C. The defendant is from a different city.  D. The Magistrate does not have the support of the Ubar or military.

D.  

18.   A Magistrate who is also a miderator can:  A. Use a witness's profile as evidence in court.  B. Handle both IC legal matters and OOC rules issues.  C.  Use an IM as evidenc in a trail.  D. Change a Gorean law without the Ubar's cinsent.

B.

 19. Which of these is a Magistrate most likely to rule on in a typical court hearing?  A. The proper placement of a city's defenses.  B.  A plan to raid a neighboring city for spoils.  C. A dispute over the authenticity of a slave's pedigree papers.  D. The proper ritual for a Scribe's oath.

C.

 20. Who would be responsible for raising an objection if an Advocate's testimony is deemed irrelevant to a case?  A, The accuser or plainiff.  B. The defense advocate.  C. The Chief of the Warrior Caste.  D.  A Magistrate,

B.

 21. When an Advocate presents a client's case, which of these is their most important responsibility?  A. To ensure that all legal protocols are followed in court,  B. To win the case for their client, using persuasive rhetoric and legal arguments.  C. To ensure that all favts are presented in a neutral manner,  D. To ensure that all witnesses are sworn to tell the truth.

B.

 22. Which of the following would be an appropriate punishment for a first-time thief who has no prior convictions?  A. A fine of 500 gold tarns.  B. Ear notching, so that they can be identified as a thief.  C. Death by impalement.  D. Enslavement to the city for one year.

B.

23. A Gorean Magistrate who is also a moderator would have to use both OOC rules and IC laws to deal with which of these situations?  A. A female slave who refuses to speak to a free person. B. A man's private dispute with his companion over a contract.  C. An assassin who is caught trying to enter a city.  D. A thief who is caught with a stolen lute.

A.

 24, Who is responsible for ensuring that all legal documents are properly filed and maintained?  A. The guardsman who arrested the defendant.  B. The defendant's Advocate. C. The Ubar or Adminidtrator,  D. A legal clerk or a scribe.

D.

 25. When a Magistrate is sentencing a person, which of these is not considered a valid punishment?  A. The removal of a limb.  B. Enslavement. C. A fine of money.  D. The taking away of a Home Stone.

D.

 26. A Magistrate's officr is located in the lower quarters of the city. Who is this meant to serve?  A. The High Caste members.  B. The lower castes.  C. The Magistrate's personal friends and familly.  D. The slaves.

B.

 27. The Magistrate is not lehally permitted to do which of the following?  A. To order a slave's testimony be takrn under torture.  B. To demand that a free woman prove she is not a slave.  C. To change a city law without a decree from the Ubar or High Council.  D. To order the arrest of a citizen.

C.

 28. What kind of clothing can a Magistrate not wear in a courtroom?  A. A plain brown garment.  B. A leather tunic and pants.  C. A white robe.  D. A silk robe.

B.

29.  Who would be responsible for presenting a case on behalf of a citizen who is accusing a merchant of fraud?  A. The citizen themselves.  B. A Litigator for tr city.  C. An Advocate.  D. The Magistrate, as the Magistrate would be the one to hear the case.

C.

30.  Which of the following is the most important skill for a Magistrate?  A. The ability to read and write without flaw.  B. The ability to entertain two conflicting ideas at the same time.  C. The ability to speak for hours without pause.  D. The ability to fight with a sword.

B.

 31. A Magistrate's authority to make a legal decision is not limited by:  A. The caste of the Magistrate.  B. The personal wealth of the Magistrate.  C. The authroity of the Ubar.   D. The laws of the city.

B.

 32. Who would be responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate a legal claim?  A. All of the abovr.  B. A citizen.  C. An Advocate.  D, The city's ruler.

A.

 33. Which of the following is not a duty of a Magistrate?  A. To administer the oath to a citizen.  B. To enforce a legal sentence.  C. To oversee a dual between two warriors.  D. To advise a citizen on a legal matter.

D.

 34. When a Magistrate is presented with a case, their first duty is to:  A. Determine if they have jurisdiction over the case.  B.  Ensure that a slave's testimony is taken under torture. C. Find a creative punishment for the accused.  D. Contact the Ubar for instructions.

A.

 35. Which of these is not a task for an Advocate?  A. Drafting lega documents for a client.  B. Making a final ruling in a criminal case.  C. Advising a client on a legal dispute.  D. Conducting legal research for a case.

B. 

36. Who is responsible for determining which laws appy in a given case?  A. The Advocate.  B. A Magistrate.  C. The Accuser.  D.  The Head of the Scribe Caste.

B.

 37. What is the penalty for a slave striking a free person?  A. Death, by a Magistrate's order.  B. No penalty, as a slave's actions are irrelevant to the law.  C. A fine, paid by the slave's owner.  D. A severe beating , followed by enslavement.

A.

 38. Which of the following is a duty of an Advocate?  A. To decide if a case should be heard in court. B. To enforce a legal sentence.  C. To administer the oath to a citizen.  D. To counsel a client on the best legal options.

D.

 39. What is the primary difference between an Advocate and a Ligigator?  A. A Litigator prosecutes criminal cases, while an Advocate defends citizens in civil cases.  B. A litigator is a judge, while an Advocate is a legal representative.  C. A Litigator is a Scribe, while an Advocate is not.  D. A Littigator is a sub-caste of the Merchant Caste, while an Advocate is not.

A.

40.  In a Gorean trial, who would typically speak on behalf of the city to prosecute a criminal case?  A. A City Scribe.  B. A City Litigator.  C. The Ubar or Administrator.  D. A Magidtrate.

D.

 41. Which of the following whould be the most important skill for a Magistrate?  A. The ability to speak for hours whthout pause. B. The ability to fight with a sword,  C. The abilitu to write in a variety of styles.  D. The ability to be impartial.

D.

42. A Gorean Magistrate who is also a moderator whould have to use both OOC rules and IC laws to deal with which of these situations?  A. A female slave who refuses to speak to a free person.  B. A man's private dispute with his companion over a contract.  C. An assassin who is caught trying to enter a city.  D. A thief who is caught with a stolen lute.

A.

 43. Which of the following is not a duty of a Magistrate?  A. To administer the oath to a citizen.  B. To enforce a legal sentence.  C. To oversee a duel between two warriors.  D. To advise a citizen on a legal matter.

D.

 44. Who would be responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate.  A. All of the above.  B. A Citizen.  C.  An Advocate.  D, The city's ruler.

A.

 45.When a Magistrate is presented with a case, their first duty is to:  A. Determine if they have jurisdiction over the case.  B.  Ensure that a slave's testimony is taken under torture.  C.  Find a creative punishment for the accused.  D. Contact the Ubar for instructions.  

A.

 46. Which of the following is a duty of an Advocate?  A. To decide if a case should be heard in court.  B. To enforce a legal sentence.  C. To administer the oath to a citizen.  D. To counsel a client on the best legal options.

D.

 47. What is the primary difference between an Advocate and a Litigator?  A. A Litigator prosecutes criminal cases, while an Advocate defends citizensin civil cases.  B. A Litigator is a judge, while an Advocate is a legal representative.  C, A Litigator is a Scribe, while an Advocate is not.  D. A litigator is a sub-caste of the Merchant Caste, while an Advocate is not.

A.

 48. In a Gorean trial, who would typically speak on behalf of the city to prosecute a criminal case?  A. A City Scribe.  B. A City Litigator.  C. The Ubar or Afministrator.  D.  A Magistrate.

B.

49. What is the primary difference between a Magistrate and a Litigator?  A. A Magistrate's primary duty is to the law, while a Litigator's is to their client.  B. A Magistrate is a man, while a Litigator is a woman,  C. A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer. D. A Magistrate's job is to enforce laws, while a Litigator's job is to break them.

C.

 50. Which of these is the most important for a Magistrate when sentencing a criminal?  A. The criminal's social standing.  B. The criminal's reputation.  C.  The sentence's book-based authenticity and practicality in an SL Context.  D. The criminal's caste.

C.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Gorean Advocate's Test: 50 Difficult Questions

 

Gorean Advocate's Test: 50 Difficult Questions

An Advocate's role in Gorean society is to be the legal representative and voice of a client, navigating the law on their behalf. These questions test a deep understanding of their duties, ethics, and strategic mindset, going beyond simple definitions.

---

Section 1: Foundational Role & Duties

1. True or False: An Advocate's primary duty is to ensure the law is applied fairly.

   • False. That is the Magistrate's role. An Advocate's duty is to their client.

2. Your client is accused of a crime. Who would be responsible for pronouncing the final verdict?

   • The Magistrate.

3. As an Advocate, your loyalty to your client supersedes your loyalty to your caste.

   • True. An Advocate's duty is to their client's interests.

4. A Scribe is accused of a crime. As an Advocate, can you represent them?

   • True. You can represent any citizen.

5. What is the primary difference between an Advocate and a Litigator?

   • A Litigator specializes in criminal cases, while an Advocate handles civil cases.

6. A Magistrate has the authority to change a city's law.

   • False. Only an Ubar or the High Council has this power.

7. A Magistrate's office is primarily used for legal work, while an Advocate's is for managing a citizen's private business.

   • False. An Advocate's office is for their legal work, but it is for a citizen's business, which may be a private matter.

8. As an Advocate, you must remain silent during a trial.

   • False. You must speak on behalf of your client.

9. An Advocate's authority to make a legal decision is limited by: a) The laws of the city. b) The personal wealth of the Advocate. c) The authority of the Ubar. d) All of the above.

   • d) All of the above.

10. A Magistrate and an Advocate are the same.

    • False. A Magistrate is a judge, while an Advocate is a lawyer.

11. What is the Gorean name for a lawyer who prosecutes a criminal case?

    • Litigator.

12. Who has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court?

    • A Magistrate.

13. A Magistrate's office is primarily used for conducting trials and administrative work.

    • True.

14. What is a key duty of an Advocate in a criminal trial?

    • Calling witnesses to support a client's defense.

15. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt?

    • The Magistrate presiding over her case.

---

Section 2: Evidence & Strategy

16. A slave's testimony can be used as direct evidence in a Gorean court.

    • False. It is only valid if taken under torture.

17. A slave's testimony is taken under torture, and it is believed by the Magistrate. Your client, a free man, is found guilty. What is your strategy?

    • You would appeal the Magistrate's decision, arguing that a slave's testimony, even if taken under torture, is not always valid and that the Magistrate was biased.

18. Your client's testimony is the only evidence in a case. What is your strategy?

    • You would argue that your client is a man of honor and that their word is enough. You would also try to find other witnesses or evidence to support your client's testimony.

19. A Magistrate rules that a piece of evidence is inadmissible. What is your course of action?

    • You would argue against the Magistrate's ruling and would try to show why the evidence is relevant. If the Magistrate still rules against you, you would try to find other evidence to support your client's case.

20. A witness for the prosecution is a friend of your client. What is your strategy?

    • You would question the witness's testimony and try to show that they are biased. You would also try to find other witnesses to support your client's case.

21. A witness for the prosecution is a slave of your client. What is your strategy?

    • You would argue that a slave's testimony is not valid unless taken under torture. You would also argue that a slave is the property of your client and that their testimony is therefore biased.

22. Your client is accused of a crime. The only evidence is a witness's testimony. What is your strategy?

    • You would question the witness's testimony and try to show that they are a liar. You would also try to find other witnesses or evidence to support your client's case.

23. A Magistrate rules that your client's testimony is not valid. What is your course of action?

    • You would appeal the Magistrate's decision and would try to show why your client's testimony is valid.

24. Your client is accused of a crime. The only evidence is a written document. What is your strategy?

    • You would question the authenticity of the document and would try to show that it is a forgery. You would also try to find other evidence to support your client's case.

25. Your client is accused of a crime. The only evidence is a slave's testimony, taken under torture. What is your strategy?

    • You would argue that a slave's testimony, even if taken under torture, is not always valid and that the Magistrate was biased.

26. What is the difference between a judgment and a plea?

    • A judgment is the final decision of a court, while a plea is a formal statement of guilt or innocence.

27. Who would be responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate a legal claim?

    • Any citizen, an Advocate, or a ruler.

28. When a Magistrate is presented with a case, their first duty is to:

    • Determine if they have jurisdiction over the case.

29. Who is responsible for ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to be heard in a trial?

    • The Magistrate presiding over the case.

30. A Magistrate's authority to make a legal decision is not limited by:

    • The personal wealth of the Magistrate.

---

Section 3: Legal & Procedural Nuances

31. A Magistrate is asked to judge a case that involves the Priest-Kings. What is your strategy as an Advocate?

    • You would argue that the case falls under the jurisdiction of the Initiate Caste, not the civil government, and that the Magistrate should refer the case to the appropriate authorities.

32. A Magistrate is asked to judge a case where a free woman from a different city is accused of a crime. She has no advocate. What is your strategy?

    • You would offer to defend her pro bono. You would argue that every free person has the right to a fair trial, and that the Magistrate should not rule against her just because she has no advocate.

33. The punishment for a thief is ear notching. In an SL context, how can an Advocate argue against this punishment without a permanent ban?

    • You would argue that a permanent ban is too harsh a punishment and that a more fitting punishment would be to force the thief to roleplay as a slave for a set number of days.

34. An Advocate, in a legal matter, claims that a Magistrate is biased against their client. What is your responsibility in such a situation?

    • You would present your evidence of bias to the Magistrate and would request a change of venue or a different Magistrate.

35. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How can an Advocate argue that the punishment is too harsh?

    • You would argue that the slave's life is not their own and that their action was a reflection of their master's will. You would also argue that a slave's life is a valuable asset and that killing them is a loss of property.

36. Your client is a free man accused of a crime. The only evidence is the testimony of a slave. What is your strategy?

    • You would argue that a slave's testimony is not valid unless taken under torture. You would also try to find other witnesses or evidence to support your client's case.

37. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How can an Advocate argue that the slave's life should be spared if the slave is pregnant?

    • You would argue that a Gorean's duty is to the propagation of the race and that the slave's life should be spared until after she has given birth.

38. A Magistrate is asked to judge a case where a slave is accused of a crime against another slave. How would an Advocate proceed?

    • You would argue that a slave has no legal standing and that the case should be dismissed. You would also argue that a slave's actions are irrelevant to the law.

39. What is the difference between a Magistrate and a Litigator?

    • A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer.

40. In a Gorean trial, who would typically speak on behalf of the city to prosecute a criminal case?

    • A City Litigator.

41. What is the primary difference between an Advocate and a Litigator?

    • A Litigator prosecutes criminal cases, while an Advocate defends citizens in civil cases.

42. A Magistrate's authority to make a legal decision is not limited by:

    • The personal wealth of the Magistrate.

43. Who would be responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate a legal claim?

    • All of the above.

44. When a Magistrate is presented with a case, their first duty is to:

    • Determine if they have jurisdiction over the case.

45. Which of the following is a duty of an Advocate?

    • To counsel a client on the best legal options.

---

Section 4: Ethical & OOC Dilemmas

46. A Magistrate who is also a moderator can use an IM as evidence in a trial.

    • False. IMs are OOC and are not valid evidence in an IC trial.

47. A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer.

    • True.

48. What is the most important skill for a Magistrate when sentencing a criminal?

    • The sentence's book-based authenticity and practicality in an SL context.

49. A Magistrate's office is located in the lower quarters of the city. Who is this meant to serve?

    • The lower castes.

50. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt?

• The Magistrate presiding over her case.

- Kati Evans

The Magistrate's Crucible

The Magistrate's Crucible: A Test of Judgment

1. A woman from a Northern city wears fur and goes unveiled. A man from a southern city, believing her to be a slave, demands her papers. She refuses, and a fight breaks out. You, a Magistrate, are summoned. How does the concept of territorial law influence your first line of questioning?

2. A newly freed slave is accused of a crime she committed while a slave. As a Magistrate, would you hear the case, and on what legal principle would you base your decision?

3. The "couched" law states that preparing to be with a slave is a crime. A free woman confesses to an Advocate in private that she was considering it, but a Magistrate only has the Advocate's testimony. How would you handle this case, given Gorean legal procedures?

4. Describe the conflict of interest a Magistrate faces when a case involves a member of their own High Caste. How might they resolve it while maintaining the integrity of the law?

5. A free man's claim on an unclaimed slave is legally valid. How might a Magistrate's ruling differ if the claim is contested by a powerful merchant guild?

6. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is typically torture and death. How might a Magistrate's sentence differ if the free person was an Ubar's companion and a public apology would serve a political purpose?

7. A Magistrate who is also a moderator must deal with a case involving a slave who, in OOC chat, insulted a free person. How would a Magistrate decide whether to handle this as an IC or OOC issue?

8. The “Frame of Humiliation” is a unique punishment. As a Magistrate, how would you justify its use for a crime that has no direct precedent for this punishment?

9. A scribe's ethical teachings amount to a "code of ethics," but a warrior's is a formal "Warrior's Code." How does this difference affect a Magistrate's judicial process when a case involves a warrior?

10. The Theft of a Home Stone is a heinous crime, but the "laws of a city extend no further than its walls." What is a Magistrate's jurisdiction if the Home Stone is stolen and taken outside the city?

11. An Administrator's focus on "civil and economic matters" influences a Magistrate's rulings, particularly in a dispute involving the Merchant Caste. How might a Magistrate balance this with the principle of caste law?

12. A Magistrate's duty is to the law, not a specific person. How would a Magistrate reconcile this principle with the duty to a guardian who asks for a favor in a legal matter?

13. Describe the distinction between a judicial temperament (Magistrate) and persuasive rhetoric (Advocate). How is this difference reflected in a courtroom?

14. A Magistrate has to enforce a law that they personally disagree with. How would they uphold their duty to the city while maintaining their personal integrity?

15. A free man accuses another of a crime, but the only evidence is the testimony of a slave. How would a Magistrate proceed, given the legal requirement of torture for slave testimony?

16. A man confesses to a crime, but a Magistrate has reason to believe he is lying to protect a powerful family member. How would a Magistrate proceed, given the Gorean view on confession and truth?

17. The punishment for a thief is ear notching. In an SL context, how can a Magistrate enforce this punishment while maintaining the integrity of the law without a permanent ban?

18. An Advocate, in a legal matter, claims that a Magistrate is biased against their client. What would be the Magistrate's responsibility in such a situation, and how would they deal with the accusation?

19. Describe a situation where a Magistrate might have to disqualify themselves from a case. What legal principles would they use to justify their decision?

20. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How might a Magistrate justify this sentence in a way that aligns with Gorean philosophy?

21. A Magistrate is asked to judge a case between two men who are from different cities, but the crime was committed in a third city. What would be the Magistrate's first action?

22. An Advocate is a sub-caste of the Scribe Caste. How does this relationship influence a Magistrate's relationship with an Advocate in a legal dispute?

23. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How might a Magistrate deal with a situation where a slave, in self-defense, strikes a free man who is attacking them?

24. A Magistrate, as a citizen, can be a witness in a legal dispute. How might this affect their ability to preside over the case?

25. A free woman is accused of a crime. Her husband, a powerful warrior, threatens a Magistrate. How would a Magistrate deal with the situation while upholding the integrity of the law?

26. Describe a situation where a Magistrate might be asked to judge a case that involves the Priest-Kings. What would be the Magistrate's first step?

27. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How might a Magistrate deal with a situation where the slave is pregnant?

28. A Magistrate is asked to judge a case where a free woman from a different city is accused of a crime. She has no advocate, and no one is willing to speak for her. What would a Magistrate do?

29. A Magistrate is asked to judge a case where a slave is accused of a crime against another slave. How would a Magistrate proceed, given the Gorean legal principle that slaves are property?

30. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How might a Magistrate deal with a situation where a slave is ordered to strike a free person, and the slave does so?

31. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death. How might a Magistrate deal with a situation where a slave is asked to strike a free person, and the slave does so without being ordered to?

32. What is the Gorean name for a judge? (Magistrate)

33. A Magistrate is a civil officer who administers the law. (True)

34. A Magistrate has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court. (True)

35. The most important skill for a Magistrate is the ability to be impartial. (True)

36. A Magistrate is responsible for maintaining order in the courtroom. (True)

37. A Magistrate who is also a moderator can use an IM as evidence in a trial. (False)

38. What is the most heinous crime on Gor? (Theft of a Home Stone)

39. What is the penalty for a slave claiming caste? (Death)

40. What is the penalty for a slave striking a free person? (Torture then death by impalement)

41. What is the penalty for a locksmith keeping a copy of a key he has made for another? (Death)

42. A Magistrate's first duty is to determine if they have jurisdiction over the case. (True)

43. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt? (The Magistrate presiding over her case)

44. A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer. (True)

45. Who would be responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate a legal claim? (All of the above)

46. What kind of clothing can a Magistrate not wear in a courtroom? (A leather tunic and pants)

47. Which of the following is not a duty of a Magistrate? (To advise a citizen on a legal matter)

48. Who is responsible for determining which laws apply in a given case? (A Magistrate)

49. A Magistrate's office is located in the lower quarters of the city. Who is this meant to serve? (The lower castes)

50. Who has the final say in a legal dispute between two citizens? (A Magistrate)

==========================================================

Here are detailed Gorean-context answers to the 50 questions, exploring the nuanced and often brutal principles of a Magistrate's duty.

---

The Magistrate's Crucible: A Test of Judgment (Answers)

1. Territorial Law: The Magistrate would first have to determine if the woman is truly from a Northern city and if she has diplomatic immunity or is a registered visitor. The core question is whether the laws of the southern city apply to her, or if the man's actions were a violation of diplomatic or guest protocols. A Magistrate's first line of questioning would be to establish the legal status of the woman before the altercation.

2. The "Collar Cancels the Past" Principle: The Magistrate would hear the case. The legal principle is that "the collar, by Gorean law, cancelled the past." Upon enslavement, a person's previous crimes are nullified. Therefore, a Magistrate would not hear a case for a crime committed by the woman while she was a slave, as that past life is legally gone.

3. Hearsay and Evidence: The Magistrate would dismiss the case. The free woman's confession to an Advocate is considered hearsay and is not admissible as legal evidence. The confession was made in private, and the Advocate's role is to represent a client, not to serve as a witness against them. Gorean law requires direct testimony, often under torture for slaves, to be considered valid.

4. Conflict of Interest: A Magistrate would resolve a conflict of interest by recusing themselves from the case and referring it to another Magistrate. They would justify this decision on the principle of impartiality and the need to maintain the integrity of the law. A Magistrate must not be seen as biased or as protecting their own caste.

5. Claim vs. Power: The Magistrate's ruling might be influenced by the Merchant Guild's power, as "gold has no caste." While the man's claim is legally valid, the guild's influence and the Magistrate's need to maintain a relationship with them could lead to a compromise. The Magistrate might encourage the man to settle for monetary compensation or for a different slave, rather than risk alienating the guild.

6. Sentencing and Political Prudence: A Magistrate's sentence might be influenced by the political need for a public apology. The punishment for a slave striking a free person is torture and death, but a Magistrate could use their discretion to impose a more politically expedient punishment, such as a severe public whipping, followed by the slave being returned to the owner, with an understanding that the slave would be put to death privately.

7. OOC vs. IC: The Magistrate would handle this as an OOC issue and dismiss the case. The insult was made in OOC chat and does not apply to the Gorean legal system. The Magistrate's primary duty would be to address the slave's OOC behavior as a violation of sim rules, and not as an IC crime.

8. Justifying the Sentence: A Magistrate would justify the use of the “Frame of Humiliation” by arguing that the punishment is for a crime that has no direct precedent, and that the punishment is fitting for the crime. It is a way to set a new precedent for a specific crime.

9. Caste Codes and Law: A Scribe's code of ethics is a set of guidelines, while a Warrior's is a formal, binding code. This difference would affect a Magistrate's judicial process by requiring them to treat the Warrior's code as a formal legal document, while a Scribe's code of ethics would be a guideline that may be used in a case.

10. Territorial Law: A Magistrate's jurisdiction is limited to the city's walls. However, the theft of a Home Stone is a crime that would likely be prosecuted by the Ubar and the High Council, with the full force of the military, rather than a Magistrate, regardless of where the Home Stone was taken.

11. Administrator's Influence vs. Caste Law: A Magistrate would balance this by acknowledging the Administrator's focus on "civil and economic matters," but would also uphold the caste law of the Scribe Caste. They would justify their ruling on the grounds that the integrity of the Scribe Caste is paramount, and that a Magistrate's duty is to uphold the law, regardless of the political climate.

12. Law vs. Personal Favor: A Magistrate's duty is to the law, not a specific person. A Magistrate would reconcile this by recusing themselves from the case and referring it to another Magistrate. They would justify this on the grounds that their personal relationship with their guardian would be a conflict of interest.

13. Temperament vs. Rhetoric: A Magistrate's role is to be impartial, while an Advocate's is to be persuasive. This difference would be reflected in the courtroom by the Magistrate's calm and reserved demeanor, while the Advocate's demeanor would be passionate and persuasive. The Magistrate's job is to apply the law, while the Advocate's is to win the case.

14. Upholding Duty vs. Personal Integrity: A Magistrate would uphold their duty to the city by enforcing the law as written, but they would do so with a heavy heart. They would justify this on the grounds that the law is paramount and that their personal feelings are irrelevant.

15. Slave Testimony: A Magistrate would proceed by ordering the slave's testimony to be taken under torture. This is the legal requirement for a slave's testimony to be considered valid. The Magistrate would then weigh the slave's testimony against the free man's, and would have the final say.

16. Confession and Truth: A Magistrate would proceed with caution. They would question the man and his powerful family member, and would look for evidence to support the confession. If they believe the man is lying, they would charge him with perjury.

17. Punishment and Integrity: A Magistrate would enforce this punishment by recording the name of the criminal and the offense, but would not force them to roleplay a permanent disfigurement. They would justify this on the grounds that a roleplay sim is not a real city, and that a Magistrate's duty is to the integrity of the law, not to the literal punishment of a criminal.

18. Bias and Accusation: A Magistrate would handle this by recusing themselves from the case and referring it to another Magistrate. They would justify this on the grounds that their impartiality has been called into question and that a fair trial would be impossible.

19. Conflict of Interest: A Magistrate would have to disqualify themselves from a case where the defendant is a member of their own family, a friend, or an enemy. They would justify this on the grounds that their personal feelings would be a conflict of interest.

20. Punishment and Gorean Philosophy: A Magistrate would justify this sentence by stating that the slave's action was a violation of the natural order of things, and that the punishment is a deterrent to others. They would justify this on the grounds that a Gorean's duty is to maintain the natural order of things, and that a Magistrate's duty is to enforce the law that supports it.

21. Jurisdiction and Law: A Magistrate's first action would be to determine if they have jurisdiction over the case. They would ask where the crime was committed and if the city's laws apply. They would then refer the case to the appropriate jurisdiction if it is not their own.

22. Caste and Advocate: A Magistrate and an Advocate are both of the Scribe Caste. This would influence their relationship in a legal dispute by requiring them to be respectful of each other, even when they disagree. They would justify this on the grounds that they are both of the Scribe Caste and that their shared duty is to the law.

23. Self-Defense and Law: A Magistrate would handle this by charging the slave with striking a free person, but they would take the self-defense into consideration. The Magistrate would justify this on the grounds that a slave's duty is to their master, and that a slave's life is not their own.

24. Witness and Law: A Magistrate, as a citizen, can be a witness in a legal dispute. This would affect their ability to preside over the case by requiring them to recuse themselves from the case and referring it to another Magistrate. They would justify this on the grounds that they would have a conflict of interest.

25. Warrior's Threat and the Law: A Magistrate would handle this by upholding the law, regardless of the Warrior's threats. They would justify this on the grounds that the law is paramount and that their personal safety is irrelevant.

26. Priest-Kings and Law: A Magistrate would handle this by referring the case to the Initiate Caste. They would justify this on the grounds that a case involving the Priest-Kings falls under the jurisdiction of the Initiate Caste, not the civil government.

27. Pregnancy and Law: A Magistrate would handle this by ordering the slave to be put to death, but they would delay the execution until after the slave had given birth. They would justify this on the grounds that a Gorean's duty is to the propagation of the race, and that a Magistrate's duty is to enforce the law that supports it.

28. Representation and Law: A Magistrate would proceed by appointing a scribe to defend her. They would justify this on the grounds that every free person has the right to a fair trial.

29. Slave vs. Slave: A Magistrate would proceed by dismissing the case. They would justify this on the grounds that a slave has no legal standing and that a slave's actions are irrelevant to the law.

30. Slave's Action and Law: A Magistrate would handle this by dismissing the case. They would justify this on the grounds that a slave's actions are not their own, but rather a reflection of their master's will.

31. Slave's Action and Law: A Magistrate would handle this by torturing the slave and then putting them to death. They would justify this on the grounds that a slave has no right to strike a free person, even without being ordered to.

City if Teletus on Gor

Location and Economy

• Location: Teletus is an island city in the Thassa, the great Gorean sea. It is mentioned alongside other islands like Tabor and Scagnar, and is described as being "offshore from Torvaldsland."

• Port and Trade: It functions as a "free port," like Helmutsport and Schendi, and is primarily controlled by merchants. The governance of its port is described as being similar to that of the "exchange islands," with a focus on being "heavily trafficked" over being "strictly policed" (Hunters of Gor, p. 43). This makes it a significant hub for trade, including ships from allies and foes alike.

---

Governance and Society

• Political Structure: The city is a member of the Vosk League, where the High Council is the "body sovereign in the league." This council is composed of representatives from member towns and is responsible for appointing leaders, such as the commander of the league's forces (Renegades of Gor, p. 359).

• Calendar: Like many Gorean cities, Teletus maintains its own calendar (Raiders of Gor, p. 1-2).

• Sardar Journey: There is a custom in Teletus (and other islands) where a family receives a gold tarn disk if their son makes the journey to the Sardar Mountains as requested by the Initiate Caste before he turns 25 (Priest-Kings of Gor, p. 161).

• Military: The city has a navy, and its "navy captain" has the power to sink rogue ships and capture their crews (Raiders of Gor, p. 248).

• Demographics: Teletus is described as having a large "low caste" population that outnumbers the "high caste" citizens, leading to a significant power dynamic in their society (Raiders of Gor, p. 248).

---

Alliances and Conflicts

• Allies: Teletus is a member of the Vosk League. The city is mentioned as part of the "Salerian Confederation," where its military is engaged in conflict (Fighting Slave of Gor, p. 306).

• Rivalries: Teletus is a fierce rival of Port Kar, and its citizens were proud of a naval victory against the pirates (Raiders of Gor, p. 248). They are a member of an alliance that opposes Tyros (Conspirators of Gor, p. 161).

• Political Instability: The high number of Low Caste citizens and the proximity of rivals like Port Kar likely make Teletus's political situation complex and at times, unstable.

Courtrooms

Gorean courtrooms are not a single type but rather a variety of spaces that all share a few key features designed to emphasize authority, power, and the seriousness of the law. They range from grand, purpose-built halls to simple platforms in a busy market. 

Formal Courtrooms

The most formal courtrooms are often housed in monumental public buildings, such as a Chamber of the Council or a Cylinder of Justice. These structures are designed to be awe-inspiring:

• Tiered Seating: Council chambers often feature benches arranged in tiers, with each tier representing one of the five High Castes, and color-coded to match their robes (e.g., white for Initiates, blue for Scribes). This visually reinforces the social hierarchy.

• Elevated Judge's Throne: The judge's seat is almost always elevated on a "dais," a "throne," or a high desk, raised several feet in the air. This forces others to "look upward," creating a psychological feeling of being "overshadowed, intimidated, and awed" before the power of the law.

• Dedicated Areas: Courtrooms have clearly defined areas for all participants: tables for the prosecution and defense, and a "dock" or "cage" to confine the defendant.

Ad-Hoc and Specialized Venues

Justice on Gor is not confined to formal buildings. Hearings and trials can also take place in less formal, specialized settings:

• Wharves and Markets: Praetors and magistrates often hold court from a simple platform or a high desk on the docks or in a public market, adjudicating disputes and enforcing rules of commerce.

• Military Garrisons: The police of the arsenal in Port Kar have their own court to handle thieves, suggesting a specialized judicial function within a military or administrative complex.

• Private Rooms: In more clandestine or complex cases, legal proceedings (such as confirming an enslavement) can occur in a small, private room that is essentially an ad-hoc courtroom.

---

Key Features of Gorean Courtrooms

• Judicial Attire: Judges and magistrates wear specific robes of office, often with fillets or ribbons, to denote their rank and role.

• Defendant's Status: Defendants, especially women, are often stripped of their veils and sometimes their clothing to make them more vulnerable and easily identifiable. They are frequently bound or confined in a cage, emphasizing their helplessness before the law.

• Audience and Atmosphere: Court proceedings are often public events with a crowd in attendance. The atmosphere can be highly charged, with Gorean applause for a verdict or, conversely, jeering and cries of rage.

• Testimony: A significant part of the judicial process is the gathering of testimony, often from slaves, which in Gorean courts is "commonly taken under torture" to ensure veracity.

• Symbolism: Legal authority is visually represented by the Home Stone (if a Home Stone has been taken), the throne of the Ubar, and the physical elevation of the judge. The courtroom itself is a space where the power of the city is made manifest.

- Kati Evans

=================================================================

Physical Characteristics and Layout

• Elevated Judge's Throne: The Ubar's seat is described as a "throne of the high judge, ... raised several feet in the air, that one must feel overshadowed, intimidated, and awed before it, so arranged that one must look upward."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 317

• Dedicated Courtroom Areas: A courtroom has a stage with a "throne of the high judge, the table of the prosecution, the table of the defense, the dais of questioning, and the dock, a cage, in which the defendant was held."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 317

• Court as a Public Building: A "law court" is mentioned as a "public building" structured similarly to the "house of the Administrator."

  • Reference: Dancer of Gor, Book 22, Page 281

• Specialized "Black Courts": Brundisium is noted for having a "Black Court" which is a "facility in which Assassins are recruited and trained."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 85

• Torture Devices: "Clerks of the court mount the stage and begin to ignite braziers and lay out implements and devices of torture."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 340

---

Procedural and Legal Aspects

• Presumption of Guilt: The Gorean legal system operates on a "presumption of guilt," as "a defendant would not have been charged and brought to trial in the first place, not unless there was a presumption of guilt."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 315

• Unreliable Testimony: The "testimony of slaves, in a Gorean court, is commonly taken under torture." This is based on the theory that it will "guarantee a veracious testimony," though in practice, the slave will "tell the judge whatever he wishes to hear."

  • Reference: Mariners of Gor, Book 30, Page 42

• Defendant's Attire: A defendant may be "denied the privilege of the veil" to make them "more vulnerably recognizable" and to allow the judge and jury "to read what they can from the defendant's features."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 318

• Documented Evidence: "Hundreds of documents had been entered into the court records, certified as uniformly negative." These documents are the "major source from which witnesses had been selected."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 317

• Limited Appeal: The text describes cases as "minor" and mentions a Magistrate holding "court" where a fraudster is sentenced to be "stripped ... and a sign be put about his neck," with the sentence seemingly enacted immediately.

  • Reference: Kajira of Gor, Book 19, Page 67 and 68

---

Key Roles and Power Dynamics

• Ubar as Supreme Judge: "The Ubar ... is the supreme ruling judge." He can preside over trials, and his will is "the law" and "the law is he."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 312

• Court Officers: "Officers of the court, by order of the magistrate, removed her garments."

  • Reference: Hunters of Gor, Book 8, Page 156

• Clerks: Clerks are present at the court, and it is their job to "mount the stage and begin to ignite braziers and lay out implements and devices of torture."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 340

• Litigators/Advocates: A "prisoner under indictment" has an Advocate to "assist in your defense."

  • Reference: Warriors of Gor, Book 37, Page 308

• Specialized Courts: A separate "court of the arsenal" is mentioned for thieves, where a "female thief would be sentenced ... to service ... in a straw-strewn cell in one of Port Kar's penal brothels."

• Reference: Hunters of Gor, Book 8, Page 304

- Kati Evans

===================================================================

The Twenty Questions to Ask a Magistrate - How Skilled are They?

 

Questions on Legal Theory and Precedent

1. Stare Decisis and Judicial Discretion: A binding appellate precedent from your jurisdiction is based on a legal principle that you believe has been rendered obsolete by a recent, and more persuasive, decision from a different circuit. The facts of the case before you are almost identical to the binding precedent. How do you approach this situation, and what factors do you weigh in your decision to either follow the precedent or distinguish your case?

2. Statutory Interpretation: You are presented with a statute that has multiple, plausible interpretations. One interpretation aligns with the legislative history and intent, while another, more literal reading, leads to a just and equitable outcome in the specific case before you. Which approach do you favor, and why? What is your general philosophy on judicial activism versus judicial restraint?

3. Jurisdictional Complexity: A defendant in a criminal case has filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the court lacks jurisdiction because the alleged crime occurred in a contested border zone between your state and a neighboring one. Both states claim jurisdiction. What is your process for resolving this issue, and what legal principles would you apply to determine the proper venue?

Questions on Judicial Conduct and Ethics

4. Recusal: A long-time friend of yours, with whom you have a close personal relationship, appears as a witness in a high-stakes civil case before you. What steps do you take, and what is your reasoning for either recusing yourself or continuing to preside over the case? Discuss the importance of not just actual bias but also the appearance of bias.

5. Ex Parte Communications: An attorney involved in a difficult and protracted case before you sends a detailed email to your clerk, ostensibly for scheduling purposes, but also containing subtle arguments about the merits of a pending motion. How do you handle this communication, and what is your ethical obligation to the opposing counsel and the parties?

6. Sentencing Philosophy: A young first-time offender pleads guilty to a serious non-violent felony. The sentencing guidelines recommend a significant prison sentence, but you are also presented with compelling evidence of the offender's rehabilitation and potential for a productive life. How do you balance the principles of retribution, deterrence, and rehabilitation in reaching a fair sentence? What role does judicial compassion play in your decision-making?

Questions on Courtroom Management and Procedure

7. Pro Se Litigants: A litigant representing themselves in a complex civil case is clearly outmatched by the opposing counsel. The pro se litigant is attempting to introduce evidence that is technically inadmissible under the Rules of Evidence, but which is essential to their case. How do you manage the proceeding to ensure fairness without abandoning your role as a neutral arbiter?

8. Media and Public Relations: A highly publicized case is before you, and the media is aggressively requesting access to sensitive documents and private hearings. There are concerns that media coverage could prejudice a potential jury pool. How do you balance the principle of open justice with the right to a fair trial, and what are the specific procedures you would follow to manage this situation?

9. Contempt of Court: A defendant in your courtroom becomes belligerent, using profanity and disrupting the proceedings. The defendant has a history of mental health issues. How do you respond to the contemptuous behavior, and what considerations guide your decision to impose a sanction, or to address the underlying issues?

Hypothetical Scenarios and Legal Application

10. The Unreliable Witness: A key witness for the prosecution in a criminal trial gives testimony that is riddled with inconsistencies, but the witness's credibility has not been directly impeached. There is no other direct evidence linking the defendant to the crime. What is your role as the magistrate in this situation, and how do you instruct the jury on the proper way to weigh witness testimony?

11. Technological Evidence: You are presiding over a case where the primary evidence is a series of encrypted messages and deleted data from a computer. The defense is challenging the chain of custody and the reliability of the forensic methods used to recover the data. How do you handle the Daubert or Frye challenge to the expert testimony, and what is your standard for admitting this type of evidence?

12. Conflict of Laws: A civil dispute involves parties and events in multiple states. The laws of each state differ on a critical issue, and the choice-of-law provision in the contract is ambiguous. How do you go about determining which state's law should apply to the case?

Questions on Personal Philosophy and Judicial Temperament

13. Balancing Efficiency and Justice: The court is facing a massive backlog of cases. You are under pressure to move cases along quickly. A civil case before you requires a substantial amount of time to hear all the evidence and arguments, but the parties' claims are complex and require thorough review. How do you manage this pressure and balance the need for judicial efficiency with the imperative to ensure a just and fair outcome?

14. Responding to Criticism: Your ruling in a high-profile case is heavily criticized by a member of the public and a prominent politician. How do you handle this public criticism, and what is your responsibility, if any, to defend your decision?

15. The Unpopular Decision: You are faced with a case where the law, as you interpret it, requires a decision that is widely unpopular with the community. The public sentiment is strongly against the outcome. How do you approach your ruling, and what is your responsibility to explain your decision to the public?

Questions on Systemic Issues

16. Access to Justice: What are the most significant barriers to access to justice in the legal system today, and what is the role of a magistrate in addressing them within the confines of their courtroom and administrative duties?

17. Implicit Bias: How do you recognize and guard against your own implicit biases when making decisions, particularly in cases involving diverse parties and complex socio-economic issues? What specific steps do you take to ensure fairness and impartiality?

18. The Impact of a Guilty Plea: In a criminal proceeding, a defendant who maintains their innocence, but has limited resources, chooses to plead guilty to a lesser charge to avoid the risk of a more severe sentence at trial. How do you manage this situation, and what is your role in ensuring the plea is made knowingly, voluntarily, and with a factual basis, even when the defendant's innocence is plausible?

19. Judicial Innovation: What is an example of a procedural or technological innovation you have seen or would like to see implemented in the court system, and how would it improve the administration of justice?

20. The Role of the Magistrate: A layperson asks you to explain the fundamental difference between the role of a magistrate and a trial judge. How do you articulate this distinction, and what do you see as the unique and most important contributions of a magistrate to the judicial system?

=================================================================

Here is a framework for what an expert magistrate's response to each question might entail. A strong answer would demonstrate:

1. Legal Nuance: The ability to cite and apply relevant legal principles (e.g., stare decisis, statutory interpretation rules, rules of evidence).

2. Ethical Awareness: Recognition of ethical dilemmas and the importance of judicial canons.

3. Judicial Temperament: A calm, reasoned, and impartial approach to difficult situations.

4. Practical Experience: An understanding of courtroom dynamics and the practical implications of a ruling.

5. Self-Awareness: The ability to acknowledge personal limitations and biases.

Here is an example of what a strong response to a few of the questions might look like:

---

1. Stare Decisis and Judicial Discretion

Expert Response Framework: A candidate would explain that the principle of stare decisis is a cornerstone of the legal system, providing predictability and stability. They would state that a binding precedent from their own jurisdiction must be followed. However, they would also discuss the nuanced ways to address the situation. This could include:

• Distinguishing the case: Arguing that the facts of the current case, even if similar, are materially different from the precedent, thus allowing the court to reach a different conclusion.

• A "Reluctant Ruling": Explicitly stating on the record that while the court is bound to follow the precedent, it finds the reasoning in the other circuit's decision more persuasive and urges a higher court to reconsider the matter.

• Avoiding a "head-on collision": Acknowledging the precedent without directly challenging it and instead focusing the ruling on a different, non-conflicting legal principle.

4. Recusal

Expert Response Framework: An expert would immediately recognize that the core issue is not just actual bias, but the appearance of bias. The candidate would likely state that recusal is the only appropriate course of action, even if they believe they can be impartial. Their response would include:

• Citation of Authority: Reference to the Judicial Code of Conduct which governs such situations.

• Ethical Obligation: An explanation that maintaining public confidence in the judiciary is paramount.

• Procedural Steps: A description of the process, which would involve immediately disclosing the conflict to all parties and their counsel and explaining the reason for recusal.

7. Pro Se Litigants

Expert Response Framework: An experienced magistrate would explain their duty to ensure a fair trial while remaining a neutral arbiter. They would detail the balancing act required:

• Explaining the Rules: The magistrate would take care to explain the Rules of Evidence and court procedures to the litigant in plain English, without "doing their job for them."

• Providing Latitude (within limits): Acknowledgment that some leniency may be appropriate for technical violations, such as allowing a witness to provide a narrative rather than strict Q&A, as long as it doesn't prejudice the other side.

• Maintaining Neutrality: Emphasizing that while they can explain the rules, they cannot advise the litigant on legal strategy, question witnesses on their behalf, or make arguments for them.

• Offering Resources: Mentioning the availability of legal aid services or court-provided pro se handbooks.

---

For each of the other questions, a strong response would follow a similar pattern: identifying the core legal or ethical dilemma, discussing the relevant principles and rules, and explaining the practical steps the magistrate would take to resolve the issue in a manner that upholds the integrity of the court.

Gorean Advocate's Test: 100 Questions

 

Gorean Advocate's Test: 100 Questions

Section 1: The Basics (Questions 1-25)

These questions test a fundamental understanding of the Advocate's role.

1. True or False: An Advocate's primary duty is to represent their client's interests. (True)

2. An Advocate's loyalty is to the city's laws, and not to a specific client. (False)

3. What is the primary goal of an Advocate in a legal dispute? (To win the case for their client.)

4. An Advocate is a judge. (False)

5. What is the main difference between an Advocate and a Litigator? (A Litigator specializes in criminal cases, while an Advocate handles civil ones.)

6. An Advocate's work is primarily done in the courtroom. (False; most of their work is done in their office.)

7. Who is responsible for raising objections during a trial? (The Advocate or Litigator.)

8. Is an Advocate a member of the Scribe Caste? (True)

9. Can a woman be an Advocate? (True)

10. Who has the authority to issue a summons to a citizen? (A Magistrate.)

11. A Magistrate and an Advocate are the same. (False)

12. What is a key skill for an Advocate? (Legal research, argumentation, communication, etc.)

13. Who is responsible for maintaining order in the courtroom? (The Magistrate.)

14. A Magistrate has the authority to change a city's law. (False)

15. What is the Gorean name for a lawyer who represents a client? (Advocate or Litigator.)

16. The most important skill for an Advocate is the ability to be impartial. (False; this is a key skill for a Magistrate.)

17. Who is responsible for ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to be heard in a trial? (The Magistrate.)

18. Who is responsible for making the final decision in a trial? (The Magistrate.)

19. An Advocate's duty is to a specific client. (True)

20. An Advocate is a judge. (False)

21. What is a key duty of an Advocate in a criminal trial? (Calling witnesses to support a client's defense.)

22. An Advocate must remain silent during a trial. (False)

23. An Advocate has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court. (False)

24. A Magistrate's office is primarily used for conducting trials and administrative work. (True)

25. An Advocate's office is primarily used for legal work, not for managing a citizen's private business. (False; their office is for legal work, but for a citizen's business, which may be a private matter.)

---

Section 2: Legal Concepts (Questions 26-50)

These questions test knowledge of specific legal concepts relevant to an Advocate's work.

26. What does the term "jurisdiction" mean in a legal context? (The legal authority a court has to hear a specific type of case.)

27. Who has the final say in a legal dispute between two citizens? (The Magistrate.)

28. True or False: An Advocate's primary duty is to the law, not to a specific client. (False)

29. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt? (The Magistrate presiding over her case.)

30. Who has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court? (A Magistrate.)

31. What is the Gorean name for a lawyer who prosecutes a criminal case? (Litigator.)

32. What is the primary duty of a Litigator in a criminal trial? (To prosecute the case on behalf of the city.)

33. Who is responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate a legal claim? (Any citizen, an Advocate, or a ruler.)

34. What is the penalty for a slave claiming caste? (Death.)

35. What is the penalty for a slave striking a free person? (Torture then death by impalement.)

36. What is the most heinous crime on Gor? (The theft of a Home Stone.)

37. What is the penalty for a locksmith keeping a copy of a key he has made for another? (Death.)

38. What is the penalty for a first-time thief who has no prior convictions? (Ear notching.)

39. What is the penalty for murder of a Free, other than in self-defense? (Exile, torture, or death by impalement.)

40. What is the penalty for the rape of a FW, other than by her FC? (Torture and death by impalement.)

41. What is the primary reason that a Free Woman can be subjected to enslavement? (A crime or debt.)

42. A Magistrate is not legally permitted to do which of the following? (To change a city law.)

43. What kind of clothing can a Magistrate not wear in a courtroom? (A leather tunic and pants.)

44. Who would be responsible for presenting a case on behalf of a citizen who is accusing a merchant of fraud? (An Advocate.)

45. Who is responsible for determining which laws apply in a given case? (A Magistrate.)

46. A Magistrate's first duty is to determine if they have jurisdiction over the case. (True)

47. Who has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court? (A Magistrate.)

48. What is the primary difference between an Advocate and a Litigator? (A Litigator prosecutes criminal cases, while an Advocate defends citizens in civil cases.)

49. In a Gorean trial, who would typically speak on behalf of the city to prosecute a criminal case? (A City Litigator.)

50. What is the primary difference between a Magistrate and a Litigator? (A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer.)

---

Section 3: Advanced Applications (Questions 51-75)

These questions require a more nuanced understanding of Gorean legal principles.

51. What is the difference between a judgment and a plea? (A judgment is the final decision of a court, while a plea is a formal statement of guilt or innocence.)

52. Who would be responsible for making a formal request to a Magistrate to investigate a legal claim? (Any citizen, an Advocate, or a ruler.)

53. When a Magistrate is presented with a case, their first duty is to: (Determine if they have jurisdiction over the case.)

54. Which of the following is a duty of an Advocate? (To counsel a client on the best legal options.)

55. What is the primary difference between an Advocate and a Litigator? (A Litigator prosecutes criminal cases, while an Advocate defends citizens in civil cases.)

56. In a Gorean trial, who would typically speak on behalf of the city to prosecute a criminal case? (A City Litigator.)

57. A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer. (True)

58. A Magistrate's office is located in the lower quarters of the city. Who is this meant to serve? (The lower castes.)

59. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt? (The Magistrate presiding over her case.)

60. What kind of clothing can a Magistrate not wear in a courtroom? (A leather tunic and pants.)

61. What is the most important skill for an Advocate? (The ability to be impartial.) (False) (The most important skill for an Advocate is the ability to win the case for their client, while the most important skill for a Magistrate is the ability to be impartial.)

62. Who is responsible for ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to be heard in a trial? (The Magistrate presiding over the case.)

63. What is the primary difference between a Magistrate and a Litigator? (A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer.)

64. In a Gorean trial, who would typically speak on behalf of the city to prosecute a criminal case? (A City Litigator.)

65. What is the primary difference between a Magistrate and a Litigator? (A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer.)

66. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt? (The Magistrate presiding over her case.)

67. What is the most important skill for a Magistrate? (The ability to be impartial.)

68. Who has the authority to issue a summons for a citizen to appear in court? (A Magistrate.)

69. What is the most important skill for a Magistrate when sentencing a criminal? (The sentence's book-based authenticity and practicality in an SL context.)

70. What is the primary difference between a Magistrate and a Litigator? (A Magistrate is a judge, while a Litigator is a lawyer.)

71. A Magistrate's office is located in the lower quarters of the city. Who is this meant to serve? (The lower castes.)

72. Who has the authority to declare a Free Woman to be a slave as a punishment for a crime or debt? (The Magistrate presiding over her case.)

73. Who is responsible for ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to be heard in a trial? (The Magistrate presiding over the case.)

74. A Magistrate who is also a moderator can: (Handle both IC legal matters and OOC rules issues.)

75. Which of these is a Magistrate most likely to rule on in a typical court hearing? (A dispute over the authenticity of a slave's pedigree papers.)

---

Section 4: Hypotheticals & Ethics (Questions 76-100)

These questions explore complex situations and ethical dilemmas for an Advocate.

76. A free woman from a different city is accused of a crime in your city. She has a son, a free man, who is also a scribe. He wants to defend his mother. Can he? (Yes, he can, as he is a free man and a scribe.)

77. A man is accused of theft. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. Can she defend him? (Yes, she can, as she is a free woman and an advocate.)

78. A man is accused of a crime. He has a slave who is a skilled scribe and can write a defense for him. Can the slave defend him in court? (No, a slave has no legal standing.)

79. A man is accused of a crime. He has a slave who is a skilled scribe and can write a defense for him. Can the slave write a defense for him, but a free man or woman presents it? (Yes, a slave can write a defense for a free person, but a free person must present it in court.)

80. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. Can the slave write a defense for him, but the advocate presents it? (Yes, a slave can write a defense for a free person, but a free person must present it in court.)

81. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. Can she be his advocate? (Yes, she can, as she is a free woman and an advocate.)

82. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is not an advocate. Can she defend him? (No, a free woman who is not an advocate has no legal standing to defend a man in court.)

83. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is not an advocate. He has a scribe friend who is an advocate. Can the scribe friend defend him? (Yes, a scribe friend who is an advocate can defend a man in court.)

84. A man is accused of a crime. He has no money to hire an advocate. What happens? (A scribe from the city can be appointed to defend him.)

85. A man is accused of a crime. He has no money to hire an advocate. He has a scribe friend who is not an advocate. What happens? (A scribe friend who is not an advocate has no legal standing to defend a man in court.)

86. A man is accused of a crime. He has no money to hire an advocate. He has a slave who is a skilled scribe. What happens? (A slave has no legal standing to defend a man in court.)

87. A man is accused of a crime. He has no money to hire an advocate. He has a scribe friend who is an advocate. Can the scribe friend defend him for free? (Yes, a scribe friend who is an advocate can defend a man for free.)

88. A man is accused of a crime. He has a scribe friend who is an advocate. The scribe friend is a woman. Can she defend him? (Yes, a scribe friend who is an advocate and is a woman can defend a man in court.)

89. A man is accused of a crime. He has a scribe friend who is an advocate. The scribe friend is from a different city. Can she defend him? (Yes, a scribe friend who is an advocate and is from a different city can defend a man in court.)

90. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She is from a different city. Can she defend him? (Yes, a wife who is an advocate and from a different city can defend a man in court.)

91. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. He has a scribe friend who is an advocate. They both want to defend him. Can they? (Yes, both a wife and a scribe friend who are advocates can defend a man in court.)

92. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. Can the slave assist her with legal research for the case? (Yes, a slave can assist an advocate with legal research.)

93. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. Can the slave assist her with legal research for the case, and can the slave's testimony be used in court? (No, a slave's testimony is only valid if taken under torture.)

94. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. Can the slave's testimony be used in court, even if it is not taken under torture? (No, a slave's testimony is only valid if taken under torture.)

95. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. The slave's testimony is taken under torture. Can the slave's testimony be used in court? (Yes, a slave's testimony is only valid if taken under torture.)

96. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. The slave's testimony is taken under torture, but the slave's testimony is not believed by the Magistrate. What happens? (The Magistrate has the final say.)

97. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. The slave's testimony is taken under torture. The slave's testimony is believed by the Magistrate. What happens? (The Magistrate has the final say.)

98. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. The slave's testimony is taken under torture. The slave's testimony is believed by the Magistrate, but the Magistrate's decision is overruled by the Ubar. What happens? (The Ubar's decision is the final say.)

99. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. The slave's testimony is taken under torture. The slave's testimony is believed by the Magistrate, but the Magistrate's decision is overruled by the Ubar. The Ubar's decision is challenged by the High Council. What happens? (The Ubar's decision is the final say, but the High Council can influence it.)

100. A man is accused of a crime. He has a wife, a free woman, who is also an advocate. She has a slave who is a skilled scribe. The slave's testimony is taken under torture. The slave's testimony is believed by the Magistrate, but the Magistrate's decision is overruled by the Ubar. The Ubar's decision is challenged by the High Council, but the Ubar has the military's support. What happens? (The Ubar's decision is the final say.)